| Set | No. | Name | Rarity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | 60 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Base Set — Unlimited | 60 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Team Rocket | 64 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Gym Heroes | 63 | Blaine's Ponyta | Common | |
| Gym Challenge | 64 | Blaine's Ponyta | Common | |
| Legendary Collection | 87 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Expedition Base Set | 126 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Aquapolis | 102 | Ponyta | Common | |
| FireRed & LeafGreen | 76 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Delta Species | 78 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Diamond & Pearl | 94 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Stormfront | 71 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Arceus | SH11 | Ponyta | Rare | |
| Arceus | 46 | Ponyta | Uncommon | |
| Arceus | 72 | Ponyta | Common | |
| HS—Triumphant | 72 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Generations | 14 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Steam Siege | 16 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Evolutions | 19 | Ponyta | Common | |
| SWSH Black Star Promos | SWSH013 | Galarian Ponyta | Promo | |
| Sword & Shield | 81 | Galarian Ponyta | Common | |
| Shining Fates Shiny Vault | SV047 | Galarian Ponyta | Rare Shiny | |
| Astral Radiance | 21 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Silver Tempest | 21 | Ponyta | Common | |
| 151 | 77 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Temporal Forces | 26 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Base Set (Shadowless) | 060 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Cosmic Eclipse | 23 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Destined Rivals | 29 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Flashfire | 14 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Miscellaneous Cards & Products | SWSH13 | Galarian Ponyta - SWSH013 (General Mills Promo) | ||
| Stellar Crown | 19 | Ponyta | Common | |
| Team Up | 17 | Ponyta | Common |